[Date Prev][Date Next][Thread Prev][Thread Next][Date Index][Thread Index]
[Xen-API] Please welcome Jan Beulich as Xen committer & revisions to Xen governance
Dear Xen developers,I wanted to announce that Jan Beulich has been nominated for as Xen Hypervisor committer and confirmed by vote by the other Xen committers (which are Keir Fraser, Tim Deegan and Ian Jackson).
Jan's Contribution ==================Jan has made a tremendous contribution to the project over the years and was was one of the top 3 contributors to the project for several years. Just to quote a few stats
- 2009 : 107 patches changing 11746 lines of code - 2010 : 147 patches changing 7613 lines of code - 2011 : 204 patches changing 2655 lines of code Congratulations!I do have to apologize that we did not entirely follow the new governance process as described at http://www.xen.org/projects/governance.html due to an oversight. The nomination and vote was meant to happen in public, but has happened in private amongst the existing committers. We will do better next time. This exercise has also shown some bugs in the process which need fixing.
Bugs in the Process =================== See http://www.xen.org/projects/governance.html)Committer vs. Maintainers: The process talks about maintainers as if they were committers and mixes some aspects of both roles. This is incorrect.
PROPOSED FIXES: - Split the role into two - What is a maintainer? - A maintainer owns one or several component in the Xen tree - A maintainer reviews and approves changes that affect their component- Note that some components will be owned by several maintainers (in that case consensus
decision making applies)- Election: new maintainers are nominated and voted for by other maintainers
- What is a committer? - A maintainer with write access to the code tree- The committer acts on the wishes of the maintainers and applies changes approved
by the respective maintainer(s).- Helps resolve disagreements between maintainers of the same component should they arise - Election: new committers are nominated and voted for only by other committers
- Allow a committer to be a sponsor for a new Xen.org project - Reflect above changes in Elections - I believe we should keep "Project Lead Elections" as it is(We could restrict elections to committers, but in practice committers will have a much higher chance to be elected. I believe we should leave things as they are.)
Please let me know your views, by responding to this thread. If there are no objections by next friday, Oct 7th, we will just update the document. And then give another week for additional discussion and the change will be considered approved.
Regards Lars _______________________________________________ xen-api mailing list xen-api@xxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxx http://lists.xensource.com/mailman/listinfo/xen-api
Lists.xenproject.org is hosted with RackSpace, monitoring our